Franklin seems like the most reasonable option (excluding trying to lure someone away from the NFL). A lot of their "targets" seem like total pipe dreams. I suppose they might be able to lure Gus Malzahn if he decides he'd rather not compete with Alabama and Saban. Franklin is the only name I've seen ESPN throw out that seems like they'd for sure take the job.
I got in a cordial but passionate debate with a good friend (a Vandy Law graduate). As a UT grad, I did some digging and examined Vandy's wins under Franklin. Here are the results as quoted from me to him via email:
"During the greatest stretch in Vandy history (aided in no small part to the downward trend at UT and some incredible scheduling "luck"), Vandy has gone to three bowl games. I concede that is unprecedented. The reason that Vandy doesn't get invites to "better" bowls is certain: scheduling. In three years, the teams that Vandy has beaten average a 4-8 record. 6 of the 23 individual victories of Vandy's came against teams who were so bad that the HC was replaced. Vandy has only beaten 4 teams in three years who were bowl eligible.
Vandy, under Franklin, has never beaten a team that finished the regular season with more than 8 wins.
Franklin's best win on paper is against an 8 win UGA squad. Close your eyes and pretend that that game isn't any different had UGA not had its whole offense sidelined playing at UT.
Now consider this, if UT scheduled like Vandy (you know, not playing Oregon and instead schedules UMASS, or UAB, a WF - teams that totaled 7 wins this season), UT would also be going to a bowl. Pay no attention to the fact that UT's western division games came against Auburn and Bama ( two of the most talented teams in the SEC with a combined 2 losses between them) to Vandy's western division games (9 losses between them, both mid pack talent wise). How about this: 10 of the 23 Vandy victories came against teams with 3 wins or less. Almost half of Vandy's wins during the greatest stretch in their history came against teams who couldn't....win....4....games."
How much have you heard about the rape case lately? I understand it's still supposedly being "investigated" but this thing has been forgotten for the most part, by many. Hell, I live in the Nashville area, my father in law is the Davidson Co Court Administrator and I've forgotten about it and heard nothing in 4+ plus months. I think very little will come of the situation period, and Franklin will be free of any wrong doing.
I can't see them stroking a check for the guy until the rape investigation is cleared.
I guess it could go the other way...if Franklin took the job, TX money might try to make the investigation go away as quickly as possible.
Agreed.
On the surface, it looks like a solid and exciting hire.
Dig down a little and its pretty shaky. Not saying he wouldn't win there, but I don't think its the slam dunk some paint it as.
He'd definitely have to adjust his style. I don't think his schtick he's used at Vandy would play very well at Texas. It would be a very Kiffin-esque hire from that aspect.
Enough with the rape scandal. Franklin didn't commit a crime and he's not on trial. The school turned the culprits in and investigated the matter themselves to catch them. There was no cover up. U people are blinded by hate for someone that's had some success against your football team.
Alot. Tennessee cannot beat James Franklin. If he gets hired away, hopefully we can start beating Vanderbilt again and move up a spot in the East.