So the committee is officially a joke

#352
#352
rjd970 said:
Nope, wrong yet again.

I’m looking objectively at a body of work. You guys are stuck on who wins the popularity contest.
Click to expand...

Your body of work is claiming that they have equal schedules and teams. While a ranking says so, that’s far from the case. You need to learn context.
 
#353
#353
JMSqb11 said:
Sure you are. You are saying that they are equal schedules because of a ranking. That means you are saying the SEC West is equal to Big 10 West because their opponents are their schedule!

You can’t claim they have equal schedules but then say their divisions aren’t equal. But hey, keep letting your boat/argument keep taking on water.
Click to expand...

You do realize SOS is based on more than what conference somebody plays in, right? It’s a part, but not the whole thing.

How could we ever determine comparative schedule strengths of independents. I guess the math would break?

And for the last time, I’m not saying anything based on opinion. I’m looking at the SOS rankings. THATS IT.

If you want my opinion, sure, the SEC West is better. We good now? But the SOS ranking is roughly the same between Bama and Wisconsin.

Your attempts at cuteness and attacks are making you look foolish.
 
#354
#354
JMSqb11 said:
Your body of work is claiming that they have equal schedules and teams. While a ranking says so, that’s far from the case. You need to learn context.
Click to expand...

That’s far from the case?

I’m game. Based on what objectively? I’m not interested in your opinion. I’m interested in your facts.
 
#355
#355
volfanngatorland said:
Better players, better wins, better coach, harder schedule.

Just off the top of my head.
Click to expand...

Harder schedule is a wash based on SOS. Better wins? Not based on the numbers.

Better coach, players? Ok, sure. So you are advocating teams get preferential treatment before the first game is played based on who’s their coach?
 
#356
#356
Opinion: I think Bama is probably...probably, the better team.

Fact: By the numbers, Wisconsin accomplished more in 2017.

Because Bama didn’t play in a championship game, we can look at the regular season. Who’s better, a 1 loss team with SOS #9, or an undefeated with SOS #14? Take the names out of the decision and just look at the numbers.
 
#357
#357
rjd970 said:
Opinion: I think Bama is probably...probably, the better team.

Fact: By the numbers, Wisconsin accomplished more in 2017.

Because Bama didn’t play in a championship game, we can look at the regular season. Who’s better, a 1 loss team with SOS #9, or an undefeated with SOS #14? Take the names out of the decision and just look at the numbers.
Click to expand...

You realize if you take out Wisconsin’s game against OSU their SOS isn’t in the same ballpark, right?

If we are going by regular season as you say, Wisconsin SOS isn’t anywhere close to #14
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#358
#358
volfanngatorland said:
You realize if you take out Wisconsin’s game against OSU their SOS isn’t in the same ballpark, right?

If we are going by regular season as you say, Wisconsin SOS isn’t anywhere close to #14
Click to expand...

Just went back and did the numbers. Wisconsin regular season SOS was 45th.
 
#361
#361
volfanngatorland said:
You realize if you take out Wisconsin’s game against OSU their SOS isn’t in the same ballpark, right?

If we are going by regular season as you say, Wisconsin SOS isn’t anywhere close to #14
Click to expand...

True, you’re right. I’m going by regular season because Bama couldn’t get to a CCG. At the end of the day both had the same number of wins before the playoffs. Wisconsin’s SOS was paid for by one loss.

So apples to apples, which is better. #9 SOS with one loss, or #14 SOS with one loss but played for a conference championship?

Conference-wise I’ll say SEC is better, but after this bowl season so far I’m not so sure.
 
#363
#363
rjd970 said:
Opinion: I think Bama is probably...probably, the better team.

Fact: By the numbers, Wisconsin accomplished more in 2017.

Because Bama didn’t play in a championship game, we can look at the regular season. Who’s better, a 1 loss team with SOS #9, or an undefeated with SOS #14? Take the names out of the decision and just look at the numbers.
Click to expand...


Feel stupid yet? I mean seriously. UW played nobody until a game they were forced to play.
 
#364
#364
rjd970 said:
True, you’re right. I’m going by regular season because Bama couldn’t get to a CCG. At the end of the day both had the same number of wins before the playoffs. Wisconsin’s SOS was paid for by one loss.

So apples to apples, which is better. #9 SOS with one loss, or #14 SOS with one loss but played for a conference championship?

Conference-wise I’ll say SEC is better, but after this bowl season so far I’m not so sure.
Click to expand...

Good chance both teams in the championship game will be from the sec
 
#366
#366
rjd970 said:
True, you’re right. I’m going by regular season because Bama couldn’t get to a CCG. At the end of the day both had the same number of wins before the playoffs. Wisconsin’s SOS was paid for by one loss.

So apples to apples, which is better. #9 SOS with one loss, or #14 SOS with one loss but played for a conference championship?

Conference-wise I’ll say SEC is better, but after this bowl season so far I’m not so sure.
Click to expand...

And you answered your own question. Who cares that they played in their conf championship game.
 
#374
#374
volfanhill said:
You play no one. The one real game they have they lose. How the hell would you put them in over OSU? So the next thought is well OSU should get in. Well they have lost twice.
Click to expand...

I know, I was agreeing with your post, playing in the conference championship is a irrelevant argument as you should not benefit from being in a weak division, it was clear if they were in the opposite division they would not have even made the championship game
 
#375
#375
I was never very good at math, but I’ll give it a shot:

UCF beat Auburn + Auburn beat Georgia and Alabama + Georgia and Alabama will play for national title + UCF never lost a game =

UCF is the best team in college football.
Click to expand...

From Twitter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top