I would take Romo over Rivers (not just for on-field performance, but for 100% less douchiness). I think enough of Aaron Rogers right now though that I'd take him over Romo. I think Rogers is ready to cut loose and disprove that Tedford products aren't winning NFL QB's.
As for Eli, yes, Eli has the hardware, but he has David Tyree's helmet to thank for that. The biggest miracle catch in superbowl history is the thing most responsible for keeping the Pats from going unbeaten.
McNabb, only because he seems like he's really been rejuvenated by a change of scenery. We'll see if it lasts, he is getting up there in age.
Palmer has always been in a weird sort of limbo in Cincinnati. Same ball park, couldn't say who is better.
I WANT Romo to do well. He is my team's QB (that's my quarterback, man :cray
but right now the problems clearly start at the offensive line. That's something you can't overcome these days. 15 years ago this franchise put together the greatest offensive line the League has ever seen. Now they've got one that couldn't stop anything without getting a holding call.