Since you think they aren't top 5 recruiters, please name me guys who are better. And I'm not talking about just getting players from your backyard like Urban Meyer or Mack Brown. Saban and Pete Carroll are the only 2 I can think of...
You are way off base. Being ranked as a top 5 recruiter on a website literally means nothing. Thompson was recruiter of the year, and now, he's probably the 4th or 5th best recruiter in Knoxville...
Look at the players they recruited. Pete Carroll said Orgeron should get as much credit as anyone for rebuilding the USC program because of his recruiting. Ask any USC fan their opinion of Orgeron. Ask Houston Nutt what he thinks of the players that Orgeron left for him (Hardy, McCluster, Snead, Oher, Laurent, etc.)...
You say you don't bring in truck loads of talent after years like that. Did you watch Ole Miss last year? They looked like they had quite a bit of talent to me. Butch Davis is in the midst of building a top notch program at a school that has been at the bottom of the ACC for a while...
I never said they were good head coaches (although I do think Davis is solid). I said good recruiters. Alot of talent can take you a long way. You've just got to be able to find it. Butch won a national championship with the most talented team in College Football history. They weren't all high rated players either. Ed Reed was a low rated (2star I think) RB out of high school. Davis saw his potential, and the rest is history...