'19 TX WR Isaiah Neyor

Exactly, it's all subjective---it can't be measured.

For the most part the Recruiting agencies are not doing any work with the exception of interviews and watching recruiting boards, offers and interviews with players, coaches and local media. Nothing new here. You don't want them watching film and making an evaluation because it would be a nightmare anyway. Plus they don't have the time to do it...
 
  • Like
Reactions: NighthawkVol
TY Hilton, Carson Wentz, J Garoppolo were all 2*

We’ve been through this a million times… these, plus (as noted above) Kelce and Jefferson… and Davante Adams, Cooper Kupp, Adam Thielen, JJ Watt, Khalil Mack, Kevin Byard… and on and on. There are legitimately a ton of those guys.

It’s really amazing. And, yes, I’d rather have a roster full of 5-stars, but it’s definitely true that there are a ton of 2-star ballers out there.

(Expand to 3-stars and you get Aaron Rodgers, Pat Mahomes and a ton more…)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sudden Impact
It’s amazing how teams recruited before Rivals, Scout, and 247 were founded. Without “stars,” how did coaches know who was good?

It was a different world then.
You'd hear by word-of-mouth about a kid who is good, then make a trip to watch him play on Friday night.
 
For the most part the Recruiting agencies are not doing any work with the exception of interviews and watching recruiting boards, offers and interviews with players, coaches and local media. Nothing new here. You don't want them watching film and making an evaluation because it would be a nightmare anyway. Plus they don't have the time to do it...
Don’t forget their little camps with kids doing drills in shorts. Go to a Rivals camp get a better rating
 
I agree it's not a perfect system. But I'm also not of the mindset that you get a 5* because Bama wanted you. There's countless reasons to realize that's false. The fact that Bama doesn't sign 25 5*s, the fact that Bama's highest rated recruits are disproportionately their best players, the fact that they're drafted high, the fact that they continually win.
Nah I agree. I didn’t mean all their recruits get five stars but they definitely get evaluated and bumped some.
 

VN Store



Back
Top