It’s hard to argue that players shouldn’t be allowed to profit monetarily from their talents, especially given the obscene amount of money that universities, broadcast outlets, sports apparel companies, coaches, and many others are making off the sport. Should there be some kind of regulation? Probably. But given where the courts have come down, doing that is a tall order for the foreseeable future.
To me, a more complicated matter is the unlimited transfer stuff. That is something that could BEGIN to get addressed through changing the transfer windows. Still lots more that needs to be done, but at least that’s a start. As long as coaches can go mercenary with little or no consequence, there is no justification in significantly limiting the players’ ability to depart for other opportunities. Even the saintly and beloved Rick Barnes was ready to leave us for UCLA just a few years ago - and the only reason he didn’t was because they couldn’t reach an agreement on $.
The danger in all of this is that college sports loses that team-centric spirit that makes it unique. The NBA has become so player-centric that I don’t know why they still have team names based in specific locations. There are few rivalries left in the NBA. It’s all about individual players — Stop referring to the LA Lakers and just call them “Team LaBron.” Since Kyrie Irvin declared that the Nets didn’t need to hire a GM because he and KD were the real GMs, I lost what little care I had left about pro basketball.
How do balance the need to give the players the freedom they are entitled to regarding pay and mobility without robbing the college game of what makes it special?