GoBigOrange86
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Nov 26, 2007
- Messages
- 15,169
- Likes
- 38,577
Living in Boulder, there was significant confidence that Butch Jones was coming to Colorado. It was even reported in one of the local papers as a done deal. I got some dirty words from people who know I'm a Tennessee fan after Jones was hired.
Facts are stubborn things. Let's settle the "Dream Job" question once and for all.
Butch Jones turned down the Colorado job before he knew whether or not he'd be able to secure an offer to coach at Tennessee. In other words, he decided a job at Cincinnati with even a shot at a UT offer was better than 15+ million dollars from Colorado.
Folks, that's a man who means it when he says "Dream Job."
Also, he'd already told Purdue to stop calling.
Here is the timeline:
On Wednesday, 12/5/2012, in the afternoon Charlie Strong comes to a decision.
Charlie Strong turns down Tennessee offer, will stay at Louisville - Pete Thamel - SI.com
Soon after, Butch Jones, lets Colorado know that 15 million is what he is willing to pay just to get the next interview at Tennessee. The Colorado AD asks one his flacks at the Denver Post to try and kneecap Butch. Mark Kiszla published this hit piece at 9:13 PM.
Mark Kiszla: Butch Jones in a gotta-get-mine, college football cash grab - The Denver Post
On Thursday, 12/6/2012, Dave Hart interviews Butch "somewhere in Kentucky". I imagine a riverboat on the Ohio River, but you make the movie however you want.
Butch Jones' name has surfaced as a possible candidate for Tennessee's head coaching job. | wbir.com
Did Butch "mull it over" when Dave Hart decided, after a long interview, that he'd found his guy? No! He woke the Cincinnati AD up at 5 AM on 12/7 to break the bad/good news. Met his players 2 hours later . . .
Tennessee Volunteers hire Butch Jones as new coach - ESPN
and hustled down to Knoxville to start work . . .
Butch Jones arrives in Knoxville : Knoxville Photo Galleries : Knoxville News Sentinel: Local Knoxville, Tennessee News Delivered Throughout the Day.
In summation, he turned down 2 BCS jobs which would have given him significant pay raises to wait for a chance to coach at the University of Tennessee. Dave Hart had no obligation to offer him the job, but once offered he was on the job in Knoxville in under 12 hours.
This is undoubtedly Coach Jones' "Dream Job". The defense rests its case.
No way Tennessee was his dream job, that he always wanted. What I think he meant was that this is one of the few gigs he considers a destination job. I do believe that he stays here as long as he does well, and as long as UT pays him well, if he does.What do y'all think about Jones saying this is his dream job?
Before he was hired, I had the attitude that the Tennessee head coaching job should be anybody's dream job.
And then, when we hired somebody who actually said it was, I thought "yeah, right, just saying what we want to hear".
As time has gone by though, I'm thinking why wouldn't it be his dream job? The SEC, the greatest traditions in the SEC, the best fan base in the SEC. Why wouldn't it be his dream job?
I wanna believe he was sincere. Whatcha think?
There's no deal. Tell me, what makes UT traditions the best? They're all unique and special to each respective team...except Vandy and UK.
We, as UT fans, think UT's are the best...but that's not being objective. Bama, Auburn, UGA, & LSU can make the same claim, and according to their fans they would be correct.
I do think he was/is sincere when he says this is his dream job. I don't think, however, that Tennessee in particular was his dream job. I think that Tennessee fits the bill of a "dream job" for a football coach. Other schools would also fit the bill.
Having said that, once he landed this particular job, he embraced it fully and now Tennessee is his dream job.
I think that- in this regard- there is a real similarity between CBJ and CBP.
What do y'all think about Jones saying this is his dream job?
Before he was hired, I had the attitude that the Tennessee head coaching job should be anybody's dream job.
And then, when we hired somebody who actually said it was, I thought "yeah, right, just saying what we want to hear".
As time has gone by though, I'm thinking why wouldn't it be his dream job? The SEC, the greatest traditions in the SEC, the best fan base in the SEC. Why wouldn't it be his dream job?
I wanna believe he was sincere. Whatcha think?
Here is what I think. Whether or not the Tennessee job was specifically Butch's dream job or if it was generally his dream job is of no concern.
I think that Butch thinks that UT is a top tier program insofar as resources, tradition, fan base, and facilities. UT is a top tier destination program. Before some Debbie Downer tries to drag that statement down, I consider the top tier of NCAA football to be about 20 teams who have comparable resources and tradition, and Tennessee is certainly on that list.
Yes, Tennessee has its own unique problems including, at times, an unreasonable fan base but a chance to take the reins of a program like this is a dream to a competent coach (and a nightmare for a coach who doesn't "get it"). UT being in the SEC presents attractions and shortcomings for a qualified coach. You get to drive a racecar against the best in the business. If you are found wanting, you will be dispatched quickly. If you find success, you will be a hero. Butch has gone all in. I admire that whether or not his statements are to be construed exactly as they appear.
Are there better schools out there? Definitively the answer is yes. There are schools where recruiting is easier, where the money is not as tight, and who have no rebuilding to do in the short term. I don't think that matters to a guy like Jones. I think that he sees UT as a destination job, one where he can make his mark where he is not being hand cuffed by the restrictions of lower tier programs where he has already found his success.
Brian Kelly left Cincy for Notre Dame, going through a similar slump as UT. Jones left Cincy for UT, a similar caliber job. Both are probably dream jobs for guys of either ilk.
I also don't really buy the whole idea that he grew up watching UT. I think he was aware of Tennessee throughout his life, and has probably seen our games televised as we typically have good national coverage. I can even buy that he respected what Tennessee was doing when he was growing up in the same way that I can respect TCU or Stanford or Michigan without following any program closely. I don't think it is a lie, at all, I just think that it is an over statement.
I do believe that Butch was probably impressed with what he saw when he brought his Bearcat team to Neyland. That would have to be one of the more impressive environments that he had ever participated in as a coach.
Bottom line: he seems incredibly grateful to be here, he seems determined to succeed and is working tirelessly. His respect for the traditions and the Tennessee legacy is compelling (But, Dooley seemed to get that part). Some of that work is already paying dividends in recruiting. At this point, there is nothing more I can ask for out of a coach.
Almost exactly how I see it.I do think he was/is sincere when he says this is his dream job. I don't think, however, that Tennessee in particular was his dream job. I think that Tennessee fits the bill of a "dream job" for a football coach. Other schools would also fit the bill.
Having said that, once he landed this particular job, he embraced it fully and now Tennessee is his dream job.
I think that- in this regard- there is a real similarity between CBJ and CBP.
An even better question is whether you think Coach Jones would leave for any of those jobs in the next 5 years.
If Jones leaves in the next five years it will be for one of two reasons, 1) he was told to leave, or 2) he got an NFL job.
I think for a Coach like Jones there is little difference between top tier programs. He wants to win and win big on a national stage. UT was the only program in the SEC that had what he needed: a vacant head coaching position and the resources to make a serious run.
Jones builds relationships, so if he moves to another school, especially in the SEC, he weakens his ability to recruit which lessons his chances to win, and win big. There is no glory there.
Kiff leaving, as much as it hurt, was fueled by a realization that while he can recruit, he can't do so well enough to win consistently in the SEC. His performance in the PAC is proof of that; stellar recruiting/sub par coaching. That is his history. It is also not the reality the majority of the time at major top tier schools.
Jones has shown that he can recruit above traditional levels at the schools he coaches, and can win games with those recruits. We haven't had a coach who could do both since the early 2000's.