Barkley is overrated, but at the same time I wouldn't compare him just by his stats. High school stats can be very misleading (playing weak opponents, large gap in talent, young players, etc) From what I have read his WR are very young and likely a cause of him forcing balls into spots he shouldn't have. You can be the greatest QB in the world, but if you dont have decent WR's your boned. Saying all that, I would still rather have Murray.